• Add description, images, menus and links to your mega menu

  • A column with no settings can be used as a spacer

  • Link to your collections, sales and even external links

  • Add up to five columns

  • November 21, 2026 7 min read

    Alternatives to Rhodes Grass Hay for Horses with EMS, PPID or Laminitis

    For owners of horses and ponies with Equine Metabolic Syndrome (EMS), Pituitary Pars Intermedia Dysfunction (PPID, commonly called Cushing's disease) or a history of laminitis, choosing the right hay is particularly important.

    Rhodes grass hay has long been a popular choice for these horses because it is generally lower in sugar and starch than many other commonly available hays. But what happens when Rhodes grass hay becomes difficult to source, or you simply need an alternative?

    The good news is that Rhodes grass isn't the only suitable forage option. Several other types of hay and fibre sources can be incorporated into a carefully managed diet.

    The key is understanding that not all hay is created equal, and even hay from the same grass species can vary considerably in its nutritional composition.

    Why Is Rhodes Grass Hay So Popular for Metabolic Horses?

    Horses with EMS and some horses with PPID experience insulin dysregulation, meaning their bodies do not regulate insulin normally. Persistently elevated insulin concentrations can damage the sensitive structures within the hoof, potentially resulting in endocrinopathic laminitis.

    While not every horse with PPID has insulin dysregulation, those that do require particular attention to their dietary sugar and starch intake.

    Rhodes grass is a warm-season tropical grass that typically contains relatively low levels of non-structural carbohydrates (NSC), making it a useful forage option for horses requiring a controlled sugar and starch diet.

    However, Rhodes grass hay is not automatically safe simply because of its variety.

    Growing conditions, maturity at harvesting, fertilisation, weather and storage can all affect its nutritional composition. Even Rhodes grass hay may contain more sugar than expected, which is why forage analysis is particularly valuable for horses with significant insulin dysregulation.

    How Much Sugar Is Too Much?

    For horses with EMS, insulin dysregulation or a history of endocrinopathic laminitis, a commonly recommended target is hay containing less than 10% NSC on a dry matter basis, although some guidelines allow up to 10–12%, depending on the individual horse.

    One complication is that laboratories may calculate NSC differently.

    When assessing a hay analysis, it is important to look at the actual sugar and starch measurements rather than relying solely on a product being advertised as "low sugar".

    In particular, ethanol-soluble carbohydrates (ESC) plus starch can help estimate the carbohydrates most likely to produce an insulin response. Some feeding guidelines instead use water-soluble carbohydrates (WSC) plus starch, so always check which measurement is being reported.

    For horses with severe insulin dysregulation or active laminitis, your veterinarian or equine nutritionist can help interpret the results and determine an appropriate target.

    What Are the Alternatives to Rhodes Grass Hay?

    1. Teff Hay

    Teff hay is one of the more promising alternatives to Rhodes grass for horses requiring a low sugar and starch diet.

    Like Rhodes grass, teff is a warm-season grass and is often naturally lower in NSC than many cereal hays.

    It can provide a useful source of long-stem fibre without excessive energy, particularly for horses that maintain their weight easily.

    However, teff hay can vary in nutritional value depending on growing conditions and harvesting maturity. It can also contain oxalates, which may interfere with calcium availability. This is worth considering when feeding teff as a substantial proportion of the diet over an extended period.

    Best suited to: Horses and ponies requiring a lower sugar, moderate to low energy forage, provided the hay has a suitable nutritional analysis and the overall diet is balanced.

    2. Low Sugar Meadow Hay

    Meadow hay can be another useful alternative, especially when a reliable, tested low sugar variety is available.

    Unlike hay made from a single grass species, meadow hay often contains a mixture of grasses. Its nutritional composition can therefore vary considerably.

    Some meadow hays are relatively low in sugar and energy, making them useful for horses with EMS or PPID. Others may contain substantial amounts of water-soluble carbohydrates, particularly if ryegrass or other higher sugar species are present.

    This makes it important to distinguish between ordinary meadow hay and meadow hay that has actually been analysed and found to contain suitably low sugar and starch levels.

    Best suited to: Horses requiring a controlled NSC intake when a tested, low sugar meadow hay is available.

    3. Lucerne Hay

    Lucerne is sometimes avoided by owners of laminitic horses because it is higher in protein and calcium than grass hay. However, this doesn't necessarily make it unsuitable for horses with EMS or PPID.

    In fact, lucerne is often relatively low in sugar and starch and can be a useful addition to the diet.

    There are a few important considerations.

    Lucerne is generally more energy dense than mature grass hay, meaning that feeding large quantities may provide more calories than an overweight horse requires. Its high protein and calcium content also need to be considered when balancing the complete ration.

    For horses that are underweight, elderly or struggling to maintain condition, lucerne may be particularly valuable.

    Some horses with insulin dysregulation can also produce an insulin response to protein-rich meals, so lucerne should not automatically be considered suitable in unlimited quantities.

    Best suited to: Horses requiring additional protein or condition, or as part of a mixed forage ration where total calories, minerals and insulin response are considered.

    4. Soaked Grass Hay

    If a suitably low sugar hay is unavailable, soaking grass hay may help reduce its water-soluble carbohydrate content.

    When hay is submerged in water, some of its soluble sugars leach out, reducing the amount consumed by the horse.

    Research has demonstrated that soaking hay for approximately 30–60 minutes can reduce its sugar content, although the effectiveness varies considerably depending on the hay, water temperature and soaking conditions.

    There are several important points to remember:

    • Soaking does not reliably make every high sugar hay safe for a laminitic horse.

    • The reduction in sugar content is variable.

    • Some minerals and other nutrients are also lost during soaking.

    • Soaked hay should be drained and fed promptly, particularly in warm weather, to minimise microbial growth.

    • The soaking water should be discarded rather than offered to the horse.

    For horses with significant insulin dysregulation, testing the hay is preferable to relying on soaking alone.

    Best suited to: Horses requiring reduced sugar intake when suitable tested forage is unavailable, with veterinary or nutritional guidance.

    5. Unmolassed Beet Pulp and Other Fibre Sources

    When conventional hay options are limited, alternative fibre sources can help supplement the diet.

    Unmolassed beet pulp, such as Speedi-Beet, provides highly digestible fibre with relatively low sugar and starch content.

    It can be particularly useful for horses that need additional calories without relying on cereal grains, including older horses with PPID that struggle to maintain body condition.

    Lucerne chaff and other appropriately formulated low sugar fibre feeds can also help provide variety and supplement the forage ration.

    However, these products are not necessarily direct replacements for long-stem hay.

    Horses require sufficient physical fibre to support normal chewing, saliva production, digestive function and natural feeding behaviour. Any substantial replacement of hay with processed fibre should be carefully planned to ensure these requirements continue to be met.

    Best suited to: Supplementing low sugar forage diets, particularly for horses requiring additional digestible fibre or having difficulty maintaining condition.

    What About Oaten, Wheaten and Barley Hay?

    Cereal hays, including oaten, wheaten and barley hay, are widely available throughout Western Australia.

    Unfortunately, they can contain substantially higher levels of sugar and starch than many mature tropical grass hays.

    Their carbohydrate content can vary considerably depending on the stage of growth, harvesting conditions and the amount of grain present in the hay.

    For this reason, they are generally not the first choice for horses with EMS, insulin dysregulation or a history of laminitis.

    While an individual batch may test within an appropriate NSC range, cereal hay should not be assumed suitable without analysis.

    The same caution applies to ryegrass hay, which can also contain substantial concentrations of soluble carbohydrates.

    Does the Amount of Hay Matter?

    Absolutely.

    Controlling sugar and starch intake is important, but horses must also receive sufficient forage to maintain digestive health.

    The amount required depends on body weight, body condition, activity level and the nutritional composition of the forage.

    Many horses at maintenance require approximately 1.5–2% of their body weight in forage dry matter per day. For example, a 500 kg horse may require approximately 7.5–10 kg of forage dry matter daily.

    For overweight horses with EMS, a veterinarian may recommend a controlled calorie restriction using appropriately selected low sugar forage.

    However, not all horses with EMS or PPID are overweight.

    Some are quite lean, particularly older horses with PPID. These horses still require controlled sugar and starch intake but may need additional calories from suitable fibre and fat sources to maintain condition.

    Restricting forage simply because a horse has EMS or PPID can create additional health and welfare problems. The aim should be to provide the right type and amount of forage, rather than simply reducing the quantity fed.

    Don't Forget About Pasture

    Even the most carefully selected hay cannot compensate for excessive sugar intake from pasture.

    For horses with insulin dysregulation, grazing can contribute significantly to overall dietary sugar intake, particularly during periods of rapid pasture growth or environmental stress.

    Pasture sugar content varies according to grass species, sunlight, temperature, moisture and growth conditions.

    Short grass is not necessarily low in sugar, and restricting grazing to particular times of day does not guarantee a safe intake.

    For horses with active laminitis, pasture access should generally be removed while the condition is being treated. Longer term grazing decisions should be guided by veterinary advice and the horse's insulin control.

    Choosing the Right Forage for Your Horse

    If Rhodes grass hay is unavailable, don't assume that you have no suitable options.

    Teff hay, analysed low sugar meadow hay, lucerne and appropriately soaked grass hay may all have a place in the diets of horses with EMS, PPID or a history of laminitis.

    The most important considerations are:

    • Choose hay based on its nutritional analysis, not just its name.

    • Aim for a suitable low sugar and starch content.

    • Consider the horse's body condition and overall calorie requirements.

    • Maintain adequate forage intake and long-stem fibre.

    • Balance vitamins, minerals and protein across the complete diet.

    • Make forage changes gradually wherever possible.

    • Work with your veterinarian to monitor insulin regulation, particularly when making significant dietary changes.

    Remember, a horse does not have to be overweight to develop insulin dysregulation or laminitis. Even a lean horse may require strict dietary management.

    Need Help Choosing an Alternative?

    At Oakford Stockfeeds, we understand how challenging it can be to find suitable feeds for horses with special dietary requirements.

    Whether you're looking for alternative hay options, low sugar fibre feeds or a suitable vitamin and mineral balancer, our team is happy to help you explore the options available for your horse.

    Visit us in store, browse our range online atwww.oakfordstockfeeds.com.au, or contact our friendly team for assistance.

    This article provides general nutritional information and is not a substitute for veterinary advice. Horses experiencing active laminitis require prompt veterinary assessment and an individually managed treatment and feeding plan.